All posts

Headhunters, and why they won’t find you a job

There is a considerable misunderstanding about how top-level executive positions are filled.  Everyone knows that headhunters – or executive search consultants as they prefer to be known – are involved, but many candidates aiming for executive positions have incorrect assumptions about the motivations of these recruiters.

The correct answer to “Will an executive headhunter find me a job?”  is No.

Headhunters are called Headhunters because they hunt heads.  They work for the client – the hiring organization – not the candidate.  If a headhunter contacts you, it’s because they are considering you for a role with the client.

They are not trying to find you a job.

So how will a headhunter help with your job search?

A significant number of senior positions are filled by headhunters.  If you want to be placed into one of these roles, you’ll need to know the headhunter – or the headhunter will need to find you.  There are no other options.

The good news is, however, that top headhunters are paid a lot of money (typically 33% of total annual compensation) to find the best candidate to meet the need of the hiring organization.  They are paid this in the expectation that they will conduct an extensive search of the market, looking for candidates in the industry and well beyond.  The aim is that they will consider both “active candidates” (the term used to describe job seekers) and “passive candidates” (those who are not necessarily proactively looking for a new role but might be open to the right opportunity.  In other words – pretty much everyone else of working age!

According to our internal research, approximately 65% of candidates longlisted on an executive search are not known to the recruiter at the beginning of the search. To put this another way – if you are the best candidate for the role, it is the job of the recruiter to find you!

Executives identified vs spoken to on a typical executive search


How do executive headhunters build the longlist?

Firstly, it’s worth noting that the vast majority of executive recruiters do not advertise positions on job boards.  Some do, of course, but generally speaking the key roles at the more important organizations are filled under a shroud of secrecy.  You can’t go to the headhunter, so you have to get the headhunter to go to you.

The longlisting stage is all about research.  The search team will aim to source potential candidates in a variety of ways:

Target company based research

If a recruiter is looking to find an executive with specific niche experience, a good starting point is likely to be the competition.  If you are hiring an airline executive for American Airlines, a good starting point might be United.  Recruiters will use a number of approaches to identify relevant executives but – more often than not – this type of research revolves around Linkedin.  A couple of hours of research can often draw up a list of executives in relevant jobs – Linkedin has been a game-changer for executive search.

Transferable skills-based research

In some cases, however, the target company based approach is not the appropriate one for the search.  Let’s take, for example, the search for a CFO at a fast-growing, cash burning, pre-IPO Internet company – a unicorn,  Here, the primary requirement is likely to be – find a CFO who can successfully deliver a fundraising exercise.  The client will need someone who has done it before, someone who has excellent relationships with investors.  Someone who is a safe pair of hands.  It is unlikely that this person will be working for a competitor (indeed, this client might not have a direct competitor).  Similarly, with a Board of Directors search.  In this case, the successful recruit is clearly not going to be coming from a competitor.  Again, the specification is likely to call for specific skills and experiences.

How do you ensure that the headhunter notices you?

Some times it just happens.  To go back to my airline industry example – if you are in the right role at the right company, you’ll be looked at.  You don’t need to do much more than have a Linkedin profile!

Of course, that is only a subset of roles.  And, more to the point, generally speaking, an executive wishes to make a “step-up” when they change jobs.  If you are currently CFO, it might be that you want to be CEO in your next role.  In this case, a headhunter is unlikely to spot you purely based on your company and job title.  Even worse, if you are currently between jobs, then you are not likely to be identified on these types of searches at all.

In these scenarios, you’ll need to work a little harder

Your executive brand

Under these circumstances, you are going to need to position yourself to be found.  You can do this in a variety of ways.  Offline, you can speak at the events, write for industry press and so on.  Headhunters regularly ask industry sources for advice and recommendations, and if you have a reputation around your sector – hopefully, a good one – you are more likely to receive these recommendations.  This obviously takes time and opportunity, however, and a more efficient approach might be to focus on your online visibility.

Being found on Linkedin

Many years ago, my mum used to say to me “Dress for the job you want, not the job you’ve got.”  I was in the boy scouts at the time, so I’m not sure it was the best advice, but there you go.  However, more generally, the advice is true and can certainly be extended to your Linkedin profile.  As of right now, I suspect your Linkedin profile talks about your current job and your history.  This might not help you if you are ready to make a transition – your 20 years in retail is not necessarily going to make you stand out as someone ready to make a move into the tech space, for example.

This is where Linkedin profile optimization comes in.  Simplistically, Linkedin profile optimization involves the following steps:

  • Work out the position you wish to be considered for
  • Work out the skills required for that role
  • Work out what terms a headhunter might search for
  • Build your profile around those terms

This strategic approach to positioning on Linkedin can significantly increase your visibility to executive headhunters.  We offer a Linkedin profile writing service and have seen optimized profiles enjoy a 1,000%+ increase in views over a seven day period – this isn’t always the case, but generally speaking, an optimization process will lead to more views from a more relevant audience.

The downside to relying on Linkedin, however, is that it is a very public and very structured platform.  Any changes you make to your profile will be visible to your colleague, your employees and – if you have one – your boss.  Furthermore, there is a limit to the amount of information you can share on the platform – and limit to what headhunters can search for.  For example, let’s say you are a recruiter who is looking for an executive with a background in consulting, working in FMCG and with experience of executing a product launch in China – while there are no doubt thousands of executives who have that experience, identifying them will not be easy.

As a result, many executives turn to services like GatedTalent to share detailed information on achievements and aspirations with our retained executive search clients.  A GatedTalent profile is free to create and immediately gets an executive onto the radar of headhunters across the globe.


The correct answer to "Will an executive headhunter find me a job?" -  No.

Headhunters will not find you a job